Torrance Attorneys Welcome George Bird As Judge

Long time Torrance criminal defense attorney George Bird is the newest member of the Los Angeles County Superior Court as he began his assignment in downtown Metro Court, Division 60. The assignment is considered one of the toughest for any bench officer due to its high case load of criminal matters, primarily DUI and driving on suspended license. Judge Bird has already received accolades from members of the defense bar for his level of professionalism, fairness and congeniality on the bench.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Entrapment Is A Defense In California

“I was entrapped by the police”. This is often heard when the police engage in sting operations to catch a criminal. But when is police conduct entrapment versus good police work? In California, entrapment occurs if the following three circumstances existed: (1) an officer communicated with the defendant before he committed the crime with which he was charged, (2) the officer’s communication included an inducement to commit the crime, and (3) the inducement was such that it would have motivated a “normally law-abiding per- son” to commit it.

What about sting operations? Most people agree that it is distasteful for officers to entice people to break laws that the officers are sworn to enforce. As the California Supreme Court observed, it’s the job of officers “to investigate, not instigate, crime.” This has also been asserted by the U.S. Supreme Court which said, “The function of law enforcement is the preven- tion of crime and the apprehension of criminals. Manifestly, that function does not include the manufacturing of crime.”

But not all sting operation rise to the level of entrapment. In the words of the California Supreme Court: It is impermissible for the police or their agents to pressure the suspect by overbearing conduct such as badgering, cajoling, importuning, or other affirmative acts likely to induce a normally law-abiding person to commit the crime. When the police go too far, the conduct may be shown to be entrapment.

If proven, Entrapment constitutes a complete defense to a crime. This means that if a jury finds that the defendant was entrapped, he goes free. It doesn’t matter that the crime was a major felony, or that the evidence against him was over- whelming, or even that his guilt was not disputed. If he was entrapped, he is entitled to an acquittal.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Police Dog Sniff Held Unconstitutional

Many searches occur every year in an effort to control illicit drugs. In this case the Court found the police went too far.
An officer pulled Rodriguez over for swerving his car onto the shoulder of the road then back into the lane. The officer ran a records check of Rodriguez and his passenger. After issuing Rodriguez a written warning, the officer asked if he would consent to a dog sniff of his car. Rodriquez refused. The officer ordered him out of the car and waited seven to eight minutes for another officer to arrive before conducting the dog sniff. The dog alerted and officers found a large bag of methamphetamine. Rodriquez was charged with intent to distribute. He moved to suppress the drug evidence on the basis that the officer had prolonged the traffic stop without reasonable suspicion in order to conduct the dog sniff. The district court denied the motion. The Eighth Circuit affirmed. The Supreme Court granted certiorari. Held: Vacated and remanded. The tolerable duration of a traffic stop is the amount of time necessary to address the traffic violation that warranted the stop and attend to related safety concerns. Although a driver’s license check, a warrant check, and an inspection of the automobile’s proof of insurance and registration are related to traffic safety concerns, a dog sniff “is a measure aimed at detecting evidence of ordinary criminal wrongdoing.” It is not an ordinary part of a traffic stop. Additionally, dog sniffs that occur within a short time following completion of a traffic stop are not “de minimis” intrusions that may be justified by the government’s interest in detecting drug trafficking. An officer may only prolong a traffic stop to conduct unrelated checks, like a dog sniff, if there is reasonable suspicion to justify detaining the individual. The Court remanded so that the Eighth Circuit could consider whether the officer had reasonable suspicion to detain Rodriguez beyond the completion of the traffic infraction investigation.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

How To Write A Character Reference Letter

A character reference letter can sometimes make the difference between a favorable and unfavorable resolution in a criminal case. You see, Prosecutors like to have documentary evidence justifying a reduction or dismissal in case the District Attorney reviews the file of they are called out on the case at a future date. The letters, if well written can also assist the lawyer in humanizing the client and making a DA feel good about offering a great deal or dropping the charges completely.

So, how to you go about writing a character reference letter and what information is important to include in the body of the document. The following is a sample of what the letter should contain:

Honorable Judge of the Superior Court
Or, “To Whom It May Concern”
(in cases where you do not want the writer to know about the nature of the case)

​Re:​(The client’s Name)

Your Honor or To Whom it May Concern:

​(Give a brief statement concerning yourself; for example, your occupation, experience, training, education, or other facts that may have some impact on your opinion as it relates to (the person for whom you are writing the letter).

​(Tell us how long you have known (the person in question) and under what circumstances; for example, friend, relative, neighbor, fellow worker, etc.)

​(Tell us your opinion as to what kind of a person he/ she is. Give specific examples of actions or conduct that show (the person in question’s) good character, responsibility, motivation, community service, church activities, military service, concern for others, or any other conduct that may be relevant.). It is important to focus in on specific character traits that may relate to the case.  For example, in a theft case the writer may want to provide detail about how honest or trustworthy a person has been.  In a domestic violence case the writer should provide detail and examples of how peaceful and non-violent the person is.  In a DUI case the writer may include information about how the person is generally responsible when drinking and always uses a designated diver when he or she had too much to drink.

​(State whether you feel (the person in question) is a law-abiding productive person and whether this alleged act was a result of unusual circumstances and out of character for him/her.) (optional)

​(State the likely effect of jail or imprisonment on (the person in question) and his/her family.) (this is optional)

​(State any adverse consequences a criminal conviction may have on (the person in question’s employment, family, friends, and acquaintances.) (this is optional)

Sign the letter​​​​​​​ here
​​​​​​​(Your Name Printed)
Your Address and phone number

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Importance Of Background Information In a Criminal Case

A criminal prosecution is typically based solely on police reports and any background checks the District Attorney may conduct. What is often left out is the “human story” behind a particular case. Police do a great job of writing about the bad in a given investigation and fail to present any personal information about the accused which may tend to “humanize” the case and be favorable to the outcome of the matter.

To be effective representing our client’s interests, we would like to know as much about our client as possible. To that end, we request our clients prepare a “social history”. We need to know where they were born, went to school, their occupational background and any ramifications a conviction will cause to their current or prospective job, something about their family, religious affiliations, any military service, charitable organizations they belong to, any awards or commendations they may have obtained, prior criminal history and anything else they can tell us about themselves that will enable us to know them better. My firm would also need to know if they have any prior or current medical condition or mental illness. The social history allows us to better know our client and thus give our attorneys more credibility in court when we can demonstrate our knowledge of our client’s background.

Many people may also have a professional Resume that they have used for employment, if so, include this along with the social history.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Effect Of An Expungement Of A Criminal Conviction

In California the law permits offenders to have there conviction expunged if they satisfy probation and have stayed out of trouble. An expungement is available for those who have completed probation, or if no probation was granted, after the lapse of one year from the date of sentence a petition may be filed under Penal Code 1203.4. The Court may also grant a dismissal in the interests of justice. What can a person expect if the petition of expungement under 1203.4 is granted?

First, under most circumstances, private employers cannot ask you about any convictions dismissed under PC 1203.4. Therefore, you generally do not have to disclose a conviction if it was dismissed or expunged under this section. What about applications for government employment or a governmental license? In theses cases, you must respond that yes you were convicted but the conviction was later dismissed. A proper response may be “Yes-Conviction Dismissed”. In California, government employers and licensing agencies (except for police agencies and concessionaire licensing boards) will generally treat you the same as if you had never been convicted of a crime.

What an expungement will not do: Your dismissed conviction can still be used to increase punishment in future cases. Further , the prior can still affect your driving privilege. The conviction will remain on your DMV record for points and priorability.

If you were ordered to register as a sex offender, you must make a different request to eliminate the sex offender registration requirement under section 290.

The expungement does not restore gun ownership rights as a general rule.

The expungement does not seal your record, the court records will remain accessible as a public record. The conviction may also prohibit you from holding public office if you were barred as a result of the original conviction.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

The Importance Of a Character Witnesses In A Criminal Case

Most people never have the misfortune of being arrested and charged with a crime but for those that do there is a big misperception about how the system actually works. When the District Attorney sees a case he or she views the person from the standpoint that they are like every other criminal they have seen and fail to see the individual as an average person, their neighbor, co-worker, etc. As a defense lawyer it is my job to “humanize” my client to allow the prosecutor to see him or her as a person deserving of a break or second chance. Therefore, in nearly every case it is important for our clients to provide us with a list of character references. This is vital to your case. We need to be able to learn more about you from those that know you very well. In this way we can prepare for court and can best present you as a “good person” who deserves the courts utmost consideration in evaluating your credibility and whether you are entitled to some leniency or a dismissal of the case, when appropriate. A list of between 3 and 20 persons who know you and can provide us information about you that is positive in nature. We need the names, addresses and home, work and cell phone numbers of these persons (when available). We need to know what they do for a living and how long they have known you.

In many cases it is helpful for the character witness to provide a written account of your good character via a “character witness letter”. In the letter we need to know how well they know you and in what context. The letter should include as many accounts of “good deeds” as is possible. Also, the letter should speak directly to the traits at issue in the case. For example, if the case is domestic violence the letter should contain a testament to you as a peaceful non-violent person. Almost every case involves honesty so that should also be referenced whenever possible.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment