
During a DUI investigation, police officers frequently ask drivers to blow into a handheld Preliminary Alcohol Screening (PAS) device on the side of the road. While prosecutors often try to use the numerical Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) from these roadside devices against a driver in court, there is a major scientific flaw when an officer overrides the machine’s built-in safeguards and performs a “manual trap” (or “manual capture”).
In this article Torrance DUI Attorney Matthew Ruff explains why when an officer manually captures a breath sample, the resulting BAC reading is not scientifically reliable and can be challenged in court.
How a PAS Device Is Supposed to Work: Automatic Capture
Modern PAS devices, such as the Alco-Sensor IV, are engineered with internal sensors designed to ensure a scientifically valid breath sample. Under normal automatic capture operation, the machine uses four strict criteria to determine if a sample is suitable: Pressure, Time, Volume, and Slope.
- Deep Lung Air (Alveolar Air): For a breath test to accurately reflect the alcohol concentration in a person’s blood, the sample must consist of “deep lung” or alveolar air, rather than “top lung” or mouth air.
- End-of-Breath Clues: In automatic mode, a sensor (thermistor) monitors breath flow, requiring a minimum volume (such as 1.2 liters) and looking for “end of breath clues,” such as a decrease in breath flow volume as the subject finishes exhaling. Once those criteria are met, the machine automatically draws a precise, fixed sample (approximately one cubic centimeter) into the fuel cell chamber.
What Happens During a “Manual Trap”?
A manual trap occurs when the police officer bypasses or disables the device’s automatic capture function and manually presses a button to force the machine to take an immediate sample while the driver is blowing.
Officers sometimes do this when a driver is having trouble blowing hard or long enough—such as when someone is injured, out of breath, or sitting on a curb after a collision. However, bypassing the manufacturer’s protocol strips away the scientific safeguards that make the test accurate:
- It Captures “Top Lung” Air Instead of Deep Lung Air: Without the machine’s sensors waiting for the end of a full exhalation, a manual capture grabs air prematurely. Top-lung or mouth air can be contaminated by residual mouth alcohol or simply fail to reflect true blood alcohol levels, leading to artificially inflated or inaccurate readings.
- No Verification of Minimum Flow or Volume: Unlike evidential breathalyzers (which enforce strict minimum flow rates, blowing times, and interfering-substance checks) or a PAS in automatic mode, a manual trap relies entirely on the officer’s subjective whim. The machine does not record the total breath volume or verify a minimum flow rate, meaning there is no objective proof that an adequate sample was ever collected.
- Failure to Meet California Scientific Standards: Under California Code of Regulations (Title 17), forensic breath samples used to determine BAC must be “essentially alveolar” in composition. When an officer overrides the machine’s automatic capture, it becomes scientifically impossible to prove the trapped air came from the deep lungs.
How This Impacts a California DUI Case
California courts require prosecutors to prove that a breath testing device was in proper working order, operated by a qualified individual, and—most importantly—properly administered using accepted scientific procedures before the results can be used against a defendant.
Furthermore, under California Vehicle Code § 23612(h), a roadside PAS test is intended merely as a field sobriety tool to help an officer establish probable cause for an arrest—not as definitive proof of a driver’s BAC at trial. When an officer bypasses the machine’s built-in science to force a manual capture, an experienced DUI defense attorney can file a Motion in Limine to exclude the unreliable numerical BAC results from ever reaching a jury.
Charged with a DUI in California? Contact Matthew Ruff Today. If you or a loved one were arrested for a DUI after taking a roadside breath test, the specific procedures the officer used can make or break the prosecution’s case. With decades of experience defending DUI cases across California—from Los Angeles and Torrance to Kern County—attorney Matthew Ruff knows how to uncover flawed police procedures and challenge unreliable breathalyzer results.
Call Top DUI Attorney Matthew Ruff at (310) 527-4100 for a confidential consultation to discuss your defense.